Dr. Angelo Ostuni & Dr. Justin Fazzolari

5.00 /5 (5 reviews)
Verified Reviews

About

Carnegie Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, located at 200 W 57th St #804, New York, NY 10019, represents the pinnacle of excellence in oral and maxillofacial surgical care, founded by the highly accomplished Dr. Angelo Ostuni, DDS, MD, in December 2015. Nestled in the iconic Rodin Building on West 57th Street, the practice draws inspiration from its prestigious neighbors—Carnegie Hall, Central Park, and Columbus Circle—creating a serene, state-of-the-art environment that blends modern luxury with clinical precision. Dr. Ostuni, a board-certified Oral & Maxillofacial Surgeon, brings nearly two decades of global expertise to the practice. A graduate of Columbia University’s College of Dental Medicine, he completed his six-year Oral Surgery residency at New York Presbyterian Hospital (Columbia University Campus) in 2008. Following his residency, he served as an Assistant Clinical Professor at Columbia until 2009, then pursued advanced training as a surgical research Fellow at the European Institute of Oncology in Milan, Italy, and worked as a surgeon at Ostuni MD – Center for Plastic Surgery in Puglia, southern Italy. Returning to New York, Dr. Ostuni honed his skills in a multi-doctor group before establishing Carnegie Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery to deliver unparalleled patient-centered care.[2][3][4] Joining Dr. Ostuni is Dr. Justin Fazzolari, DMD, MD, a board-eligible Oral & Maxillofacial Surgeon whose credentials are equally impressive. Dr. Fazzolari earned his Doctor of Dental Medicine from Harvard University and his Doctor of Medicine from Columbia University’s Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons. He completed a general surgery internship and a rigorous six-year residency in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery at New York-Presbyterian Hospital / Columbia University Medical Center. Hailing from New Jersey with an undergraduate degree in Biology from Rutgers University, Dr. Fazzolari's path reflects a commitment to top-tier education and training in both dentistry and medicine.[1] The mission of Carnegie Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery is to pursue surgical and patient care excellence, providing compassionate, high-quality services in a non-threatening, luminous office equipped with cutting-edge technology like digital radiography and 3D-Cone Beam CT. This commitment manifests in their comprehensive range of services, including dental implants, advanced bone grafting and jaw reconstruction, wisdom tooth removal, adult and pediatric dental extractions, impacted tooth exposure, orthognathic (jaw) surgery, management of oral infections and pathology, treatment of facial trauma, TMJ treatments, IV sedation, nitrous oxide inhalation, Botox, and hyaluronic acid filler injections. Both surgeons are trained in full-scope procedures, ensuring patients receive seamless care from diagnosis to recovery.[1][3][4] What sets Carnegie Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery apart is the unique synergy of Dr. Ostuni's international experience spanning NYC and Italy, combined with Dr. Fazzolari's fresh, Harvard-Columbia pedigree and dedication to teaching future surgeons through his ongoing affiliation with Columbia University. Their calm demeanors and straightforward approaches put patients at ease, fostering trust in a field often associated with anxiety. The practice's design—featuring glass doors, a delicate color palette, and LED lighting—creates an inviting space that contrasts with sterile clinical settings, enhancing patient comfort. Staffed at prestigious institutions like Mount Sinai Hospital (Dr. Ostuni) and supported by glowing patient reviews, the duo emphasizes positive, enjoyable experiences, from initial consultations to post-operative care. With over 160 positive reviews highlighting their expertise, this practice distinguishes itself not just through technical proficiency but by prioritizing personalized, compassionate outcomes. In a competitive New York landscape, Carnegie stands out for its blend of global perspectives, elite training, innovative technology, and unwavering focus on patient well-being, making it the premier choice for complex oral and maxillofacial needs.[1][2][3][5] As of 2026, with more than a decade of operation, Carnegie continues to evolve, solidifying its reputation as a beacon of surgical innovation and care in the heart of Manhattan.

Additional Details

Specialization: Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, including dental implants, bone grafting, jaw reconstruction, wisdom teeth removal, dental extractions, orthognathic surgery, IV sedation, Botox, and oral pathology
Education & Certifications: Dr. Angelo Ostuni: DDS and MD from Columbia University’s College of Dental Medicine; six-year Oral Surgery residency at New York Presbyterian Hospital (Columbia); board certified. Dr. Justin Fazzolari: DMD from Harvard University; MD from Columbia University’s Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons; general surgery internship and six-year Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery residency at New York-Presbyterian Hospital / Columbia University Medical Center; board-eligible.
Professional Memberships: Dr. Justin Fazzolari: American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons, American Dental Association, New York State Dental Association, New York State Society of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons. Dr. Angelo Ostuni: Not specified.
Services Offered: Dental implants, advanced bone grafting and jaw reconstruction, wisdom tooth removal, adult and pediatric dental extractions, impacted tooth exposure, orthognathic (jaw) surgery, management of oral infections and pathology, facial trauma treatment, TMJ treatments, IV sedation, nitrous oxide inhalation, Botox, hyaluronic acid filler injections

Contact Information

📍 200 W 57th St #804, New York, NY 10019, USA
🏢 New York

Location

Customer Reviews

Seema Patel
September 12, 2025

My review is way overdue. I had 6 wisdom teeth that needed removal, and I had postponed this procedure countless times due to fear of anesthesia and the pain. However, this office made me feel comfortable and works like a well oiled machine. Dr. Ostuni is a phenomenal oral surgeon. He is not only meticulous at what he does but he is also friendly, which is often hard to come by in medical care. I would recommend him to anyone who needs wisdom teeth extraction. You’re in exceptional hands.

Yehonatan H
November 26, 2025

Pretty amazing experience. Quoted price (2.5k for my specific x-ray 3 wisdom teeth) after insurance came out to be $375 so im pretty happy. going under felt pretty well. Healing process was tough but followed the guidelines and pain went away by day 4. Justin Fazzolari & the other workers are all so kind! Barely had to wait when I visited to be looked at

Harmonie Chang
September 19, 2025

I had to get an emergency extraction of a tooth with a super bad infection - I hadn't felt pain/the infection because the nerves were so damaged, so Dr. Fazzolari was able to see me pretty much the next day and take out the tooth. I was so surprised by how gentle he was, the tooth came out within minutes and I actually had to ask him mid-procedure if the tooth was out because I could barely feel him extract it! The practice is super nice and all the staff is so helpful. Definitely recommend if you need dental surgery, especially since they had helped me understand some insurance/billing things that a lot of other medical office I have been to don't even address.

Pluto M.
July 28, 2025

This is the third time I’ve had a wisdom tooth removed, and by far the best experience. Dr. Ostuni pulled out my tooth within 2 minutes -- no pain, no stress, no suffering. In contrast, my previous dentist took nearly 10 minutes just to find the nerve for anesthesia. The entire team here is kind, supportive, and professional. What I appreciate most is that they focus purely on care, just straightforward and excellent service. I actually left my previous dentist not just because of the painful procedure, but because the staff kept trying to sell unnecessary extras and even messed up my insurance. Highly recommend Dr. Ostuni and his team :)

Vincent Atilano
September 18, 2025

Dr. Ostuni and the team did such a good job with removing my wisdom teeth that I had to clarify if all 4 were removed or just my bottom two (all 4 were removed). If I could grow wisdom teeth again and have it removed I would definitely go back to Carnegie Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery.