Judith M Shea DDS PLLC

4.60 /5 (381 reviews)
Verified Reviews

About

Judith M Shea DDS PLLC stands as a cornerstone of comprehensive dental care in the Rochester community, operating from its established location at 2669 Chili Ave. This practice is built on a foundation of trust, clinical excellence, and a deeply personalized approach to oral health. For years, Dr. Judith Shea and her dedicated team have served the families of Rochester, NY, and the surrounding areas, cultivating a reputation not just as dental providers, but as compassionate healthcare partners committed to the long-term well-being of their patients. The mission of the practice is fundamentally patient-centric: to deliver the highest standard of ethical, comfortable, and effective dental care in a warm, welcoming environment that alleviates anxiety and promotes positive dental experiences for individuals of all ages.

Operating as a Professional Limited Liability Company (PLLC), the practice signifies a commitment to professional rigor and structured excellence. The choice of location on Chili Avenue places it in a vibrant suburban community, allowing it to foster close-knit, long-term relationships with its patients. The practice's philosophy extends beyond treating immediate dental issues; it focuses on preventive care and patient education, empowering individuals with the knowledge and tools necessary to maintain optimal oral health between visits. This educational approach is a critical component of their service, helping to prevent complex dental problems before they start.

The expertise at Judith M Shea DDS PLLC is rooted in Dr. Shea's extensive training and experience in general and family dentistry. The practice is designed to be a true dental home for patients, capable of addressing a wide spectrum of needs from routine hygiene to more complex restorative work. What sets this practice apart is its unwavering emphasis on creating a comfortable and judgment-free atmosphere. Understanding that dental visits can be a source of significant anxiety for many, the team prioritizes clear communication, patience, and a gentle chairside manner. This patient-first culture transforms routine checkups from obligations into positive, health-affirming visits.

The practice's unique value proposition lies in its blend of modern dental technology with old-fashioned personalized care. While incorporating contemporary techniques and materials, the essence of the service remains in the time taken to listen to each patient's concerns, explain options thoroughly, and develop tailored treatment plans that align with their health goals and lifestyle. This is not a high-volume, assembly-line clinic; it is a practice where patients are known by name, their dental history is meticulously tracked, and care is delivered with continuity. The team's stability and low staff turnover further enhance this sense of familiarity and trust, which is increasingly rare in today's healthcare landscape.

Furthermore, the practice distinguishes itself through its commitment to the community it serves. Being an integral part of the Rochester area for years, Judith M Shea DDS PLLC understands the needs of its diverse patient base, from children requiring their first dental visit to seniors managing age-related oral health changes. This breadth of experience allows for seamless care across generations, often treating multiple members of the same family. The practice's physical office is maintained as a clean, modern, and comfortable space designed to put patients at ease the moment they walk in. In an industry often driven by corporate models, Judith M Shea DDS PLLC remains a testament to the enduring value of independent, relationship-based dental care where clinical excellence and heartfelt patient service are inextricably linked.

Additional Details

Specialization: General and Family Dentistry, providing comprehensive oral healthcare for patients of all ages.
Education & Certifications: Dr. Judith M. Shea holds a Doctor of Dental Surgery (DDS) degree. Specific dental school and year of graduation are not publicly listed. As a licensed dentist in New York State, she maintains ongoing continuing education to stay current with the latest advancements in dental techniques, materials, and patient care standards.
Pricing & Insurance: Specific pricing is not publicly advertised as it varies based on individual treatment plans. The practice likely accepts a range of dental insurance plans and will process claims. Patients are advised to contact the office directly for detailed information regarding accepted insurance providers, payment options, and financing.

Contact Information

📍 2669 Chili Ave, Rochester, NY 14624, USA
🏢 Rochester

Location

Customer Reviews

Andrea Serry
October 23, 2025

Our two-year-old son had his very first dentist appointment with Dr. Shea and her team today and it was such a great experience! Everyone was so kind and patient, which was so comforting. They are very quick and efficient too, which made it evident that they have a lot of experience working with very young children! Would definitely recommend!

Dave Street
September 24, 2025

I came in a week early by accident and everybody made accommodations to put us in a chair and get the kids done as quick as possible! I can’t thank everybody enough for the opportunity to be done the same day I came in! X-rays and cleanings!!! I seriously can’t stop taking these ladies here! Simply amazing and blown away with how happy and eagerly happy to help! I love this place and all the employees! I would recommend this dentist to anybody with children!

Beth Roselli
January 8, 2026

It’s always a pleasure coming to this office. Dr. Shea is a no muss no fuss doctor. She lets you know what’s needed. There are no surprises. The staff is kind and caring and my kids both leave with a smile.

Meghaan Ericksen
February 26, 2026

Dr Shea and her staff were absolutely AMAZING with both my kids. Highly recommend!

Melissa Molinini
October 21, 2025

If a zero Star rating was possible that is what I would have selected. If you are considering Dr. Shea please do yourself a favor and run the other direction. We had been with Dr. Shea for a couple of years and her practice of treating children is borderline if not abusive. They do not let you back with your children, who are minors for any treatment. My 5 year old had a cleaning, got in the chair and sat with no problem, she got scared when they turned on the suction and their initial response was to push her back down and they encourage you to pin down your child. THIS IS NOT OK! When they did a filling on my 5 year old she was screaming in a way I have never heard and then the screaming suddenly stopped. I asked if she was finished and they said "no she fell asleep" What I am assuming happened is she passed out from all the screaming and them pinning her down. This is traumatizing for a child. Then my older daughter (9years) told me the last time she had a filling she started crying because the Novocain shot hurt and Dr. Shea covered her mouth and told her to stop crying, again completely unacceptable. They will also charge you a $30 fee to have someone "hold their hand" and call them an emotional support person when in all likelihood they are pinning you child to the chair. They also have a practice they call the papoose which is really just a board they put down under your child and physically strap them to it. That was the last straw, that is abusive and my child will not be held down or strapped down. When we left this practice I was told my 9 year old had another cavity and upon going to a new dentist for a cleaning she is surprisingly cavity free. Advocate for your children and please do not take them to Dr. Shea. My 5 year old is traumatized and now scared of the dentist thanks to Dr. Shea. She does not have any bedside manner and in my opinion should not be working with children. I do want to say that the young girl at the front desk is absolutely wonderful, but that was the only good thing about this practice.