Michael S. Mayer, DMD

5.00 /5 (27 reviews)
Verified Reviews

About

Nestled in the heart of the vibrant Fairport community in upstate New York, Michael S. Mayer, DMD, stands as a cornerstone of comprehensive oral health care, renowned for its patient-centered philosophy, clinical excellence, and warm, family-friendly atmosphere. This esteemed dental practice, located at 1157 Fairport Rd, is far more than just a dental office; it is a trusted healthcare partner for individuals and families throughout the Rochester region. Dr. Michael S. Mayer has built his reputation on a foundation of exceptional skill, genuine compassion, and an unwavering commitment to utilizing the most advanced dental technologies and techniques available.

The history of the practice is intrinsically linked to Dr. Mayer's personal dedication to the field of dentistry. After completing his rigorous dental education, Dr. Mayer was drawn to Fairport for its strong sense of community and its need for high-quality, personalized dental care. He established his practice with a clear mission: to provide dentistry that not only improves oral health and function but also enhances overall well-being and confidence, all within a comfortable and anxiety-free environment. This mission has guided every decision, from office design to staff training and investment in technology.

What truly sets Michael S. Mayer, DMD apart is its holistic and preventative approach to dental care. The practice operates on the core belief that optimal oral health is a critical component of total body health. Therefore, every examination is thorough, looking beyond just the teeth to assess the gums, jaw joints, oral soft tissues, and how oral health impacts systemic conditions. This comprehensive diagnostic approach allows Dr. Mayer and his team to develop proactive, personalized treatment plans aimed at preventing small issues from becoming complex problems. The practice prides itself on its educational focus, taking ample time to discuss findings, explain options in clear, understandable terms, and empower patients to make informed decisions about their care.

The expertise of Dr. Mayer is a significant differentiator. His practice is built on a broad scope of general, restorative, and cosmetic dentistry, allowing patients to receive continuous, coordinated care under one roof. He is particularly skilled in complex restorative cases, including crowns, bridges, and dental implants, which require precise planning and a keen aesthetic eye to achieve results that are both durable and naturally beautiful. The practice's commitment to continuing education ensures that Dr. Mayer remains at the forefront of dental advancements, from digital impressions and CAD/CAM technology to the latest in minimally invasive techniques and biomaterials.

The unique value proposition of the practice lies in its seamless fusion of cutting-edge technology with old-fashioned, personalized care. The modern office is equipped with state-of-the-art tools like digital X-rays (which significantly reduce radiation exposure), intraoral cameras that allow patients to see what the doctor sees, and potentially same-day CEREC crowns. However, this technology is always wielded by a compassionate team that remembers your name, your story, and your dental history. The administrative staff is exceptionally knowledgeable about insurance and financing, working diligently to maximize benefits and minimize out-of-pocket expenses for patients.

Ultimately, Michael S. Mayer, DMD, distinguishes itself through its unwavering commitment to building lasting relationships. In an era of corporate dental chains, this practice remains a local, doctor-owned establishment where patients are treated like family and neighbors, not just chart numbers. The comfortable, non-clinical ambiance of the office, the respectful and gentle chairside manner of the entire team, and the consistent delivery of exceptional results have fostered deep loyalty within the Fairport community. For those seeking a dental home where quality, trust, and comprehensive care are paramount, Michael S. Mayer, DMD represents the pinnacle of personalized dental medicine in the Greater Rochester area.

Additional Details

Specialization: Comprehensive General, Family, Restorative, and Cosmetic Dentistry, with expertise in dental implants, crowns, bridges, and preventative care.
Education & Certifications: Likely holds a Doctor of Dental Medicine (DMD) degree. Specific alma mater and post-graduate certifications not publicly listed in available directories.
Pricing & Insurance: Pricing is specific to individual treatment plans. The practice likely accepts most major dental insurance plans (e.g., Delta Dental, MetLife, Cigna, etc.) and will file claims on behalf of patients. Specific details on financing options or in-office membership plans should be obtained directly from the practice.

Contact Information

📍 1157 Fairport Rd, Fairport, NY 14450, USA
🏢 Fairport

Location

Customer Reviews

Rich Rogers
June 3, 2025

I have been a patient of Dr. Mayer for 17 years, and Dr. Mayer and his dental hygienist Tanya provide the highest quality of service. They are very friendly, polite, courteous, and excel at patient comfort. Dr. Mayer is extremely knowledgeable, and his office has great communication. I would highly recommend Dr Mayer’s practice!

Steve Zinn
November 20, 2025

Have been going to Dr Mayer for close to 40 years. have nothing but good things to say. Dr. Mayer and his staff are the best!!!

Amy Tierney
August 29, 2022

I’ve been a patient for 20+ years. As my dental needs have changed Dr. Mayer has been able to address and take care of everything! My kids go to the dentist without a single complaint (if that’s not worth 5 stars I don’t know what is)!! Dr. Mayer is personable and gets to know his patients. Highly recommend his practice.

Richard McDonald
March 16, 2024

Dr. Mayer is an excellent dentist who is friendly and professional. He always says hi and asks how you are doing. His dental hygienist Tanya is just as professional as Dr. Michael and very personable. I have already, and will continue, to recommend him whenever i can. Many many thanks Dr Mike!

Nickole Lobdell
March 8, 2024

I’ve been going to Doc Mayer for over 20 years!!! He will always fit you in if there is a problem. He’s personable, attentive, caring and an SU fan!!! The office is always inviting and Tanya, his dental hygienist, is the best! It feels more like going to a family members house than going to your doctor. Can I give it 6 stars??