Sherrill Fay, DMD MD

5.00 /5 (5 reviews)
Verified Reviews

About

Dr. Sherrill Fay, DMD, MD, stands as a distinguished figure in the field of oral and maxillofacial surgery, operating from her esteemed practice at Tribeca Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery PLLC, located at 21 Murray St, 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10007. With over two decades of dedicated experience, Dr. Fay has established herself as a beacon of excellence in a highly specialized domain that bridges dentistry and medicine, addressing complex conditions of the mouth, jaws, face, and associated structures. Graduating from the prestigious Thomas Jefferson University in 2005, Dr. Fay embarked on her professional journey armed with a dual Doctor of Dental Medicine (DMD) and Medical Doctor (MD) qualification, a rare combination that underscores her comprehensive training and ability to manage intricate surgical cases that demand both dental precision and medical acumen.[1][2]

The history of Dr. Fay's practice is rooted in her commitment to advancing patient care in oral surgery since entering the field nearly 21 years ago. While specific founding details of Tribeca Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery PLLC are not extensively documented in public records, her affiliation with this Tribeca-based entity reflects a strategic focus on serving the vibrant, diverse community of Lower Manhattan. This location in the heart of New York City positions her practice as an accessible hub for patients seeking top-tier oral surgical interventions amid the urban hustle. Dr. Fay's career trajectory includes notable affiliations with renowned institutions such as The University of Chicago Medical Center and Mount Sinai Hospital, affiliations that highlight her integration into broader medical networks and her involvement in high-caliber healthcare environments.[1]

At the core of Dr. Fay's mission is a patient-centered philosophy that prioritizes compassionate, efficient, and effective care. Her practice emphasizes ease of access, as evidenced by patient feedback noting friendly staff and straightforward scheduling processes. Accepting new patients, Dr. Fay ensures that individuals facing dental trauma, jaw disorders, or reconstructive needs receive prompt attention without unnecessary barriers. This mission extends to fostering trust through transparency and professionalism, qualities that resonate in a field where procedures can be daunting.[1]

Dr. Fay's expertise lies in oral and maxillofacial surgery, a discipline encompassing a wide array of procedures from wisdom tooth extractions and dental implants to corrective jaw surgery, facial trauma repair, and management of temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders. Her dual DMD-MD credentials enable her to perform surgeries under general anesthesia in hospital settings when required, distinguishing her from general dentists. With 21 years of hands-on experience, she brings seasoned judgment to each case, minimizing risks and optimizing outcomes. Patients benefit from her deep knowledge of anatomy, pathology, and pharmacology specific to the maxillofacial region.[1][2]

What truly sets Dr. Fay and Tribeca Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery PLLC apart is the unique value proposition of personalized, high-fidelity care in an urban setting. Unlike larger hospital departments where patients may feel like numbers, Dr. Fay's boutique practice offers intimate consultations and tailored treatment plans. Her affiliations with elite medical centers provide seamless referrals for complex cases, ensuring continuity of care. Moreover, her broad insurance acceptance—including major providers like Ameritas PPO, Delta Dental PPO/Premier, Cigna, CareFirst Blue Cross Blue Shield, and many others—removes financial hurdles, making premium surgical care attainable.[1] Patient reviews, though limited, affirm the welcoming atmosphere and operational efficiency, with comments highlighting friendly interactions and easy appointments.[1]

In a competitive New York landscape crowded with dental specialists, Dr. Fay differentiates through her holistic approach, blending surgical prowess with medical insight. Her NPI registration (1043273089) confirms her legitimacy and active status in federal healthcare systems, while the practice's phone line (212-267-3300) facilitates direct communication.[2] This commitment to accessibility, combined with unwavering expertise, positions Tribeca Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery as a preferred destination for those requiring sophisticated oral surgical solutions. Dr. Fay's enduring presence since 2005 speaks to her reliability and adaptability in evolving medical standards. Whether addressing congenital deformities, oncology-related resections, or cosmetic enhancements, she delivers results that restore function, aesthetics, and confidence. As oral health increasingly intersects with overall well-being, Dr. Fay's practice exemplifies forward-thinking care, setting a benchmark for what specialized surgery in New York can achieve. Her legacy is one of precision, empathy, and innovation, making her an indispensable resource for the community.[1][2] (Word count: 612)

Additional Details

Specialization: Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
Years of Experience: 21
Education & Certifications: Graduated from Thomas Jefferson University in 2005 (DMD, MD)
Services Offered: Oral and maxillofacial surgery services, including procedures typically handled by specialists in this field such as wisdom teeth removal, dental implants, jaw surgery, facial trauma repair (inferred from specialization)
Pricing & Insurance: Accepts Ameritas PPO, Regional Preferred Dental PPO, Regional Traditional Dental, Total Dental DPPO, DentalGuard Preferred, Delta Dental PPO, Delta Dental Premier, Sun Life Financial, Dental Complete DPPO, Dental Prime DPPO, Dental, DentalConnect PPO, Dental PPO, Dental DPPO, CareFirst Blue Cross Blue Shield, Cigna, and many others. No specific pricing information available.

Contact Information

📍 21 Murray St 2nd floor, New York, NY 10007, USA
🏢 New York

Location

Customer Reviews

Sony N
April 15, 2021

By far the best dental experience I’ve ever had. I can’t even believe it. The staff is very professional and kind. From check in to check out, they provided very pleasant service. Dr. Fay is very knowledgeable and super nice herself. My consultation was a full hour because she thoroughly explained the procedure and answered every single question I had. In no moment was she dismissive or in a rush to get me out. By the end, I felt completely comfortable going through with the surgery. Post op was another plus. The team was available when I needed them in the middle of the night and even checked in on me a few hours after our call to see if I had improved. Hands down, I absolutely recommend Dr. Fay. 5-stars do not come close to what she deserves.

Anna Marken
May 5, 2021

Cannot emphasize enough how fantastic Dr. Fay is. Not only did she do BEAUTIFUL work, but she has the best bedside manner I have ever experienced from a doctor. She took as much time as I needed to answer my questions and I was never rushed in and out of the office. After my surgery she took as much time as my mom needed to answer questions about caring for me while I recovered. In all of my follow-ups after surgery she was thorough and caring and made sure I was as comfortable as possible. I had my surgery a few days before the city shut down because of Covid and she went out of her way to open the practice for me for my immediate follow-ups even though everything in the whole world was closed. Truly an exceptional experience!!

Jarred Lowe
June 17, 2021

Two exceptional visits, years apart, consistent quality healthcare. I had two separate visits (around 8-9 years apart) to have my wisdom teeth removed. My first extraction was stellar (slightly impacted if I recall) and I had already ear-marked Dr Fay if/when I needed the remaining wisdom teeth out. Dr Fay is warm, honest, and caring [quick-witted too :)] She and her team stand out in my mind amongst healthcare providers because of their pre-op, op, and post-op care and attention to details. The best single word I can use to describe their approach is “anticipation” - they understand common concerns, they understand coming from anesthesia getting post-op care breakdown you don’t remember everything so an evening call is made, lastly they understand me personally and made me comfortable. A++

Michael O'Brien
July 27, 2020

Dr. Fay and her team were exceptional. All my concerns and fears were met with genuine care and professionalism. I was a stranger off the streets in terrible pain but was cared for and treated as a life long friend. Two visits (1 random and 1 procedure), 4 wisdom teeth, and a few days of minimal soreness is a fair price for the experience and treatment provided to me. Thank you Dr. Fay and team. Walking into your office tops my very short list of overall good decisions. Best of luck. I hope your Bday was a blast!

Kat
February 2, 2018

Dr. Fay is an absolutely amazing doctor. I'm a nightmare patient for every dentist, but Dr. Fay managed to make me feel at ease, she was wonderfully kind, patiently answered my silliest questions, and she was extremely professional and careful in her work. She didn't push me to get more work done than what was absolutely necessary, which is hard to come by these days. I highly recommend Dr. Fay!